When You and Your Buyer Simultaneously Hold Different Truths....
Why can't successful industrial leaders change - even when they know they should? It's not stubbornness. It's not bias. It's something deeper: their beliefs aren't opinions - they're truths. And you can't argue with truth. How often is that dissonance the real source of buyer objections? Understanding epistemological truths - and how to work with them instead of against them - is the key to unlocking change in your company and in your buyers.
Host Ed Marsh explores why middle-market industrial companies struggle to adapt, even when the evidence for change is overwhelming, and lays out five practical strategies for navigating buyers' deeply held beliefs.
Connect with me for more podcast episodes and periodic provocative ideas.
Website | | | |
Understanding Buyers' Truths....that Just Ain't True
Episode Recap
Summary
In this episode, Ed Marsh introduces the concept of epistemological truths — beliefs grounded in real evidence and experience that function as unassailable truth for the person holding them. He explains why these truths, not simple bias, are the real barrier to change in middle-market manufacturing companies. Using eleven common examples from industrial sales and marketing, Ed shows how two people can hold completely contradictory yet fully justified truths - and why that makes traditional persuasion useless.
He then presents five strategies for working with epistemological truths rather than against them:
-
Explore whether their truths are delivering the outcomes they need
-
Surface contradictory evidence without attacking the belief
-
Test predictions that their truths imply
-
Run premortems comparing outcomes under different assumptions
-
Follow a truth to its logical conclusion to reveal gaps
Takeaways
- What we call "bias" in business is often epistemological truth - beliefs backed by real evidence and experience
- You cannot hold two contradictory truths simultaneously, which is why change feels impossible
- The traits that made founders and Gen2 leaders successful become their ceiling
- Telling buyers they're wrong doesn't work - their truth is as justified as yours
- Companies that repeat the same messaging as competitors get deflected by buyers' existing truths
- Consultative sales and marketing must help buyers examine whether their truths serve their goals
- Creating new recognition beats forcing confrontation every time
- The political polarization analog applies directly to B2B sales conversations
- Sales reps who bring business acumen and outcomes focus can reach CEOs; those peddling specs cannot
- 84% of the time vendors are contacted, the spec doesn't change - so create projects, don't just find them
- Five practical strategies can help you navigate buyers' epistemological truths without attacking them
Takeaway Quote from Ed Marsh
- "Stop trying to convince buyers they're wrong. Start helping them discover whether their truths are serving their goals."
Outline
00:00 🧱 Perception Is Reality - Or Is It?
01:58 🔄 Why Smart Leaders Can't Pull the Trigger on Change
03:25 🗳️ The Political Polarization Analog
04:25 📚 Defining Absolute Truth, Epistemological Truth & Bias
06:35 🏭 11 Epistemological Truths Industrial Leaders Hold
08:59 🧠 Why You Can't Hold Two Contradictory Truths
11:26 ⚔️ The Sales Challenge: Competing Against Buyers' Truths
12:25 🛠️ Five Strategies to Navigate Epistemological Truths
15:41 💡 From Tactics to Transformation
16:48 🎯 Stop Convincing — Start Guiding
Understanding Your Buyers' Perspective is Critical to Success
Buyers have changed. Strong beliefs, strongly held. Risk aversion. Indecsion.
The internet, societal change, and AI are all at play. We must adapt our tactics and our messaging.
That's what I've outlined in this recent paper.
